Book a call
← All agencies

Cold email for email marketing agencies.

This is the cold email plan we'd run for an email marketing agency that writes and sends newsletters for one industry. The strongest signal on this page costs nothing to find. Sign up to their list and see what arrives.

Part 01

Is this for you?

Part 02

Your market.

Your market is every firm in your industry with a list of past clients and prospects and a reason to stay in touch. Advisors and lawyers and accountants win a lot of work through referrals and repeat clients. A good newsletter keeps their name in front of those people.

Almost none of the signals below need a tool. A test inbox and ten minutes a firm are enough.

  1. 01

    No way to sign up

    Look at the homepage and the footer. A firm with no newsletter signup is not staying in touch with anyone who visits.

  2. 02

    Signup test

    Sign up with a test inbox and wait two weeks. Silence or a single welcome email means the list exists and nobody is writing to it.

  3. 03

    An archive that stopped

    Some firms post past issues on their site. The date on the last one is the signal.

  4. 04

    Announcements instead of advice

    Emails that only share office news and holiday greetings give readers no reason to open the next one. Read one issue and it is obvious.

  5. 05

    They post on LinkedIn and not by email

    A partner who writes on LinkedIn every week already has content ready to go. It just never reaches their own client list.

  6. 06

    A paid tool sitting unused

    BuiltWith shows email platforms like HubSpot on their site. A firm paying for a tool it never sends from has already decided email matters.

Part 03

Lead list.

At small firms the owner or the managing partner decides. At bigger ones it is the marketing director. At advisory firms it is often the lead advisor.

Part 04

Lead magnet.

  1. 01

    Signup teardown

    What happened when you signed up to their list. What arrived and when and what should have arrived instead with screenshots.

    It works because it shows them a gap from the outside that they can't see from inside.

    Walk through it on a 15 minute screen share. The right fix depends on who is on their list and how they win new clients and the call is where that comes out. The fix is exactly what you do.

  2. 02

    Year of topics

    Twelve newsletter topics for the next twelve months built from their own blog posts and LinkedIn posts and the questions their clients ask.

    It works because the hardest part of a newsletter is knowing what to say.

    Go through it on a call because they'll want to swap a few topics for the ones clients raise most. Once the plan is agreed the next step is someone writing it.

Part 05

Front end offer.

  1. 01

    Next issue written and sent free

    Write their next newsletter in their voice. Set it up in their email tool and schedule it once they approve. They pay nothing.

    It works because they see the whole service in one go. The writing and the design and the send are all there and if replies come in the retainer is an easy decision.

    It starts with a 20 minute call to agree the topic and hear how they talk to clients. Deliver the draft within a week of that call.

Part 06

Emails by segment.

Each segment gets its own email because a specific email gets more replies than a general one. Split each segment by sub-industry too so the examples in the email fit the reader.

Keep each email under 100 words with one reason for writing and one line of proof and one offer and one question. The proof lines are examples of the kind of result to use. Swap in real results of your own before anything goes out.

  1. 01

    Signed up and heard nothing

    Lead with the date you signed up because it is the most personal first line you can write. Offer the teardown.

  2. 02

    No signup at all

    Lead with the missing signup and the past clients who never hear from them. Ask for a call directly.

  3. 03

    Active on LinkedIn with no newsletter

    Lead with their best post and how it would read as an email. Offer the free issue.

  4. 04

    Paying for a tool they don't use

    Lead with the tool because they already made the decision and just need someone to write. Offer the year of topics.

Part 07

Follow ups.

Send two follow ups in the same thread three to five days apart.

Part 08

From reply to meeting.

Each reply should end in a booked meeting that actually happens. The lead magnet and the offer get delivered on that call and never go out as a file to read later.

The replies below cover the three ways people say yes.

  1. 01

    Lead magnet reply

    They asked for the teardown. The call is where the fix gets matched to their list.

  2. 02

    Front end offer reply

    They want the free issue. The call gets the topic and the voice.

  3. 03

    Direct call reply

    They said yes to a call. Tell them what they'll leave with so they show up.

How much to expect.

Results aren't guaranteed and nobody honest can promise a number before the first emails go out. A few things decide how a campaign does.

The first few weeks show how the market responds. The list and the copy and the offer get sharper from there.

Want this run for you?

We build and run this campaign for one agency per industry.

This page is a starting point and a strategy we'd happily test ourselves. Working together gives us more context on your agency. That context lets us add better strategies and build better lists and offers and automations for you.

Book a call

Thirty minutes on your market and how we'd reach it.

More email marketing agencies.

See all agencies →