Book a call
← All agencies

Cold email for CRO agencies.

This is the cold email plan we'd run for a CRO agency that serves one industry. CRO stands for conversion rate optimization. The best prospects already pay for traffic. You can see their ads and click through to the page they send people to.

Part 01

Is this for you?

Part 02

Your market.

Your market is every company in your industry that pays for traffic or gets a lot of it. When clicks cost money each lost visitor is money gone.

These are the signals worth looking for.

  1. 01

    Ads pointing at weak pages

    Google Ads Transparency Center and Meta Ad Library show their ads. Click through. An ad that promises one thing and lands on a general page loses people.

  2. 02

    Slow landing pages

    Run the page their ads use through PageSpeed Insights. A slow page on phones is where paid clicks leak away.

  3. 03

    Long forms

    Count the fields on their demo or contact form. A long form asks a lot before the buyer has decided anything.

  4. 04

    Plenty of traffic

    SimilarWeb estimates their traffic. More traffic means tests finish faster.

  5. 05

    A buried call to action

    The button to book or buy sits a long scroll down the page or hides behind vague copy.

  6. 06

    Hiring growth roles

    A job post for a growth marketer means someone will soon be asked to get more from the same traffic.

Part 03

Lead list.

At smaller companies the founder or the head of marketing decides. At bigger ones it is the head of growth or the ecommerce manager.

Part 04

Lead magnet.

  1. 01

    Marked up landing page

    A marked up screenshot of the page their ads send people to with the changes worth testing first and why.

    It works because it is specific and visual.

    Walk through it on a 15 minute screen share. The right first test depends on their traffic and what a lead is worth and only they have those numbers. Running the tests is your job.

  2. 02

    Form test recording

    A recording of filling in their form on a phone with the time it took.

    It works because the buyer's frustration is right there on screen.

    Watch it together on a call. Some fields feed their sales team and some are habit and they'll know which can go. Fixing the form is often the first test.

Part 05

Front end offer.

  1. 01

    First test set up free

    Design and set up their first test on the page their ads point to. They see the result in their own numbers.

    It works because a test result is evidence and not an opinion. The testing program is the retainer.

    It starts with a 20 minute call to agree the goal and get access to the page and the analytics. Launch within two weeks of that call and let it run until it has enough traffic to call.

Part 06

Emails by segment.

Each segment gets its own email because a specific email gets more replies than a general one. Split each segment by sub-industry too so the examples in the email fit the reader.

Keep each email under 100 words with one reason for writing and one line of proof and one offer and one question. The proof lines are examples of the kind of result to use. Swap in real results of your own before anything goes out.

  1. 01

    Paid traffic to weak pages

    Lead with the ad and the page it lands on. Offer the marked up page.

  1. 02

    Long forms

    Lead with the field count. Offer the free test.

  2. 03

    Slow pages

    Lead with the phone score of their main landing page. Offer the recording.

  3. 04

    High traffic sites

    Lead with their traffic and the first test you'd run. Ask for a call directly.

Part 07

Follow ups.

Send two follow ups in the same thread three to five days apart.

  • Follow up one. Share the test idea. "The first test I'd run is {{test_idea}}. It's a small change on the page your ads already use."
  • Follow up two. Offer the setup. "Happy to set up that first test free and you'd see the result in your own numbers. The last first test we ran lifted demo bookings from 31 to 52 a month."
Part 08

From reply to meeting.

Each reply should end in a booked meeting that actually happens. The lead magnet and the offer get delivered on that call and never go out as a file to read later.

  • Answer within five minutes. Within 60 seconds is better and some agencies keep one person on replies just for that.
  • Call them in the same window when their number is in the signature or on the website. Keep it short. "Saw your reply and wanted to find 15 minutes to walk you through it. Does Tuesday at 10 or Wednesday at 2 work?"
  • Offer two specific times in every reply and send the invite the moment they pick one.
  • Put the reason for the call in the invite. Remind them the day before and an hour before so the meeting happens.

The replies below cover the three ways people say yes.

  1. 01

    Lead magnet reply

    They asked for the marked up page. The call picks the first test.

  2. 02

    Front end offer reply

    They want the free test. The call agrees the goal and sorts out access.

  3. 03

    Direct call reply

    They said yes to a call. Tell them what they'll leave with so they show up.

Three more emails and the follow ups are just below.

How much to expect.

Results aren't guaranteed and nobody honest can promise a number before the first emails go out. A few things decide how a campaign does.

The first few weeks show how the market responds. The list and the copy and the offer get sharper from there.

Want this run for you?

We build and run this campaign for one agency per industry.

This page is a starting point and a strategy we'd happily test ourselves. Working together gives us more context on your agency. That context lets us add better strategies and build better lists and offers and automations for you.

Book a call

Thirty minutes on your market and how we'd reach it.

More website design agencies.

See all agencies →

Want the other three emails?

Each of the other segments gets its own email. After them come the follow ups and what to say when someone replies. Enter your email and all of it opens straight away.

Entering your email means Dale from Casual Outbounds can send you the occasional email about cold outbound for agencies. One reply saying stop ends them.