Book a call
← All agencies

Cold email for fractional CMO firms.

This is the cold email plan we'd run for a firm that rents senior marketing leaders to companies in one industry. The best signal is a company that knows it needs a marketing leader and doesn't have one yet.

Part 01

Is this for you?

Part 02

Your market.

Your market is every growing company in your industry without a senior marketing leader. Many have junior marketers and nobody setting direction.

These are the signals worth looking for.

  1. 01

    A CMO search underway

    A job post for a CMO or a VP of marketing on LinkedIn means the seat is empty. Senior searches take months and marketing still has to run in the meantime.

  2. 02

    No marketing leader on LinkedIn

    Look at who works there. A company with a sales team and a couple of marketing coordinators and no leader above them.

  3. 03

    A recent raise

    Crunchbase shows the round. Investors expect a growth plan and marketing is a big part of it.

  4. 04

    A marketing leader just left

    LinkedIn shows job changes. A CMO who left last month leaves a team without direction.

  5. 05

    A new CEO

    A new CEO usually reviews marketing in the first few months.

Part 03

Lead list.

The CEO or the founder hires a marketing leader. At private equity backed companies the operating partner often gets involved.

Part 04

Lead magnet.

  1. 01

    First 90 days

    A written plan for what you would do as their marketing leader in the first 90 days based only on what is public about them.

    It works because it shows how you think before they pay for anything.

    Walk through it on a 20 minute call. A public plan always misses things only the CEO knows and the call is where you hear them. The next step is putting you in the seat.

  2. 02

    Board slide

    For funded companies. One slide on marketing for their next board meeting with the goals and the numbers to watch.

    It works because board meetings come around fast.

    Go through the slide on a call so the numbers match what their board expects. A ready slide solves a real problem this month.

Part 05

Front end offer.

  1. 01

    Two week diagnostic

    A fixed fee project over two weeks. Review their marketing and interview the team and deliver a plan in order of priority. Credit the fee against the first month.

    It works because they get a plan they can use either way. The best person to run the plan is the one who wrote it.

    It starts with a 20 minute call to agree who gets interviewed and what the plan must answer. Start within a week of that call.

Part 06

Emails by segment.

Each segment gets its own email because a specific email gets more replies than a general one. Split each segment by sub-industry too so the examples in the email fit the reader.

Keep each email under 100 words with one reason for writing and one line of proof and one offer and one question. The proof lines are examples of the kind of result to use. Swap in real results of your own before anything goes out.

  1. 01

    Active CMO searches

    Lead with the job post and an interim option. Offer the 90 day plan.

  1. 02

    Newly funded

    Lead with the round and the plan the board will want. Offer the board slide.

  2. 03

    Leaderless teams

    Lead with the team they have and the direction it needs. Offer the diagnostic.

  3. 04

    New CEOs

    Lead with the new CEO and ask for a call directly.

Part 07

Follow ups.

Send two follow ups in the same thread three to five days apart.

  • Follow up one. Share one priority. "The first thing I'd fix is {{priority_1}}. It's in the 90 day plan and I can walk you through the rest."
  • Follow up two. Offer the diagnostic. "If it helps we start with a two week review at a fixed fee that counts toward the first month. The last client that did it doubled demo requests the following quarter."
Part 08

From reply to meeting.

Each reply should end in a booked meeting that actually happens. The lead magnet and the offer get delivered on that call and never go out as a file to read later.

  • Answer within five minutes. Within 60 seconds is better and some agencies keep one person on replies just for that.
  • Call them in the same window when their number is in the signature or on the website. Keep it short. "Saw your reply and wanted to find 15 minutes to walk you through it. Does Tuesday at 10 or Wednesday at 2 work?"
  • Offer two specific times in every reply and send the invite the moment they pick one.
  • Put the reason for the call in the invite. Remind them the day before and an hour before so the meeting happens.

The replies below cover the three ways people say yes.

  1. 01

    Lead magnet reply

    They asked for the 90 day plan. The call fills in what only the CEO knows.

  2. 02

    Front end offer reply

    They want the diagnostic. The call agrees the interviews and the questions.

  3. 03

    Direct call reply

    They said yes to a call. Tell them what they'll leave with so they show up.

Three more emails and the follow ups are just below.

How much to expect.

Results aren't guaranteed and nobody honest can promise a number before the first emails go out. A few things decide how a campaign does.

The first few weeks show how the market responds. The list and the copy and the offer get sharper from there.

Want this run for you?

We build and run this campaign for one agency per industry.

This page is a starting point and a strategy we'd happily test ourselves. Working together gives us more context on your agency. That context lets us add better strategies and build better lists and offers and automations for you.

Book a call

Thirty minutes on your market and how we'd reach it.

More full-service marketing agencies.

See all agencies →

Want the other three emails?

Each of the other segments gets its own email. After them come the follow ups and what to say when someone replies. Enter your email and all of it opens straight away.

Entering your email means Dale from Casual Outbounds can send you the occasional email about cold outbound for agencies. One reply saying stop ends them.